Skip to Main Content
Nice Guys Pints & Pies logo topNice Guys Pints & Pies logo scroll
  • (239)-549-7542
  • niceguyspizza@gmail.com
  • 1404 Cape Coral Parkway East , Cape Coral
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Order
    pick up full menu Delivery with Uber Eat Limited Menu
  • Parties
  • Events
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
Nice Guys Pints & Pies logo topNice Guys Pints & Pies logo scroll
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Order
    pick up full menu Delivery with Uber Eat Limited Menu
  • Parties
  • Events

Our Menu

MenuVegan Menu

Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness. At any point in time, this establishment may contain any or all of the 8 major allergens: Milk, Eggs, Fish, Shellfish, Tree Nuts Peanuts, Wheat and Soybeans.

Starters

Scooby Snacks

Chevre and toasted black sesame hush puppies served with hot honey.
Garlic Knots photo

Garlic Knots

Served with housemade herb butter, garlic & parm.

Fries, Tots or Cool Ranch Tots

Served with chimichurri and sriracha crema

Truffle Fries

Sauce Flight

Includes black truffle honey mustard, chimichurri, house ketchup, citrus garlic aioli, sriracha crema, roasted garlic aioli.

Dank Nugz

Bite sized butter pretzels served with a charred jalapeño and cheese dip.

Corn Dogs* (2)

Served with black truffle honey mustard, ketchup.
Cheese Styxx photo

Cheese Styxx

House made with many cheeses.

Stinky Buns* 2.0

Pork with black garlic gochujang hoisin, Korean BBQ, pickled stuff, kimchi, cilantro-you build em.

Salads

House Salad*

Mixed greens with heart of palm, white balsamic dressing.

Man Salad*

Mixed greens with olives, gorgonzola cheese, heart of palm, prosciutto, salami, white balsamic dressing.

BYO Pizza

BYO Pizza

Small 12" | Medium 14" | Large 16"

Toppings

Pepperoni, Housemade Sausage, Salami, Ham, Banana Pepper, Spinach, Jalapeno, Black Olive, Red Onion, Cremini Mushroom, Pineapple, Anchovy, Green Pepper, Garlic, Bacon, Caramelized Onion, Kalamata Olive, Ground Beef, Corn, Fried Chicken, Pulled Pork, Prosciutto, Gorgonzola, Black Garlic, Arugula, Egg, Chorizo, Calabrese, Heart of Palm, Artichoke, Mozzarella, Provolone, Feta, Cheddar, Pickle, Egg, Pinto Bean | Small | Medium | Large

Drizzles

Calabrian Chili Oil, Habanero Aioli, Citrus Garlic Aioli, Sriracha Crema, Balsamic Reduction, General Tso's Sauce, Black Truffle Oil, Sriracha, Ranch, Roasted Garlic Aioli | Small | Medium | Large

Wings & Sauces

Wings (12)

SAUCES

Listed HOT to mellow

Xtra Hot

Super spicy (but flavorful).

Hot

Nickel city-style spicy.

Cajun Honey Butter BBQ

Nice guy's house favorite! New Buffalo classic, sweet n' spicy.

Hot Garlic Parm

Garlic herb butter with parmesan (with heat!).

Medium

Hot sauce with butter to mellow it out.

General Tso

General Tso's sauce with garlic and pineapple.

BBQ

Sweet n' tangy.

Garlic Parm

Garlic herb butter with parmesan.

Signature Pies

Truffle Shuffle

Black truffle oil, cremini mushroom, red onion, cheese, garlic, ground pepper, crisp sage • 12" | 14" | 16"
Hot Honey photo

Hot Honey

Hot honey, salami, prosciutto, garlic, tomato • 12" | 14" | 16"

My Cousin Vinny

Salami, calabrese, prosciutto, pepperoni, banana peppers, tomato, garlic, mozzarella, lettuce, onion, white balsamic, oregano • 12" | 14" | 16"

The Heart Attack

Artichoke heart, heart of palm, spinach, roasted garlic aioli, parmesan, mozzarella • 12" | 14" | 16"
Street Corn Named Desire photo

Street Corn Named Desire

Corn, mozzarella, parmesan, white American, cilantro, citrus garlic aioli • 12" | 14" | 16"

Big Mick

All beef, special sauce, lettuce, cheese, pickle, onions, sesame seed crust • 12" | 14" | 16"
Some Like It Hot photo

Some Like It Hot

Chorizo, calabrese salami, kalamata, habanero aioli, tomato sauce, fresh basil • 12" | 14" | 16"
Final Desecration photo

Final Desecration

Housemade ranch, hot chicken, bacon, jalapeno, cheese • 12" | 14" | 16"
Black Gold photo

Black Gold

Black garlic, seasonal fruit, gorgonzola, mozzarella, fresh basil, prosciutto, EVOO • 12" | 14" | 16"

Washington Carver

Peanut butter sauce, bacon, jam, mozzarella, provolone, jalapeno • 12" | 14" | 16"
General Tso's photo

General Tso's

Fried chicken, broccoli, pineapple, garlic, EVOO, general Tso's sauce, mozzarella • 12" | 14" | 16"
The Cuban photo

The Cuban

Mustard wine sauce, pulled pork, ham, pickle, swiss, mozzarella • 12" | 14" | 16"

Chicken and Waffles

Fried chicken, Belgian waffle, fruited maple, mozzarella • 12" | 14" | 16"
Don't Worry Brie Happy photo

Don't Worry Brie Happy

EVOO, garlic, caramelized onion, parmesan, cremini, arugula, brie, balsamic reduction • 12" | 14" | 16"

Chicken Pizza Masala

Garlic, parmesan, mozzarella, chicken, tikka masala sauce, cilantro • 12" | 14" | 16"

Burrizza

Pulled pork, corn, pinto bean, cilantro, lime, sriracha crema, BBQ, jalapeno • 12" | 14" | 16"

Sweets

Euro Trash Donuts

Deep Fried Oreos photo

Deep Fried Oreos

Special Pairings

Dom N' Dogs

Corn dogs (4) and a bottle of Dom Perignon

Please tell your server if you are vegan. We will be happy to prepare your meal accordingly.

Starters & Sweets

Vegan Garlic Knots

Served with housemade herb butter, garlic & nutritional yeast.

Vegan Nugz

Bite sized butter pretzels served with black truffle honey mustard.

Corn Dogs* (2)

Served with black truffle honey mustard, ketchup.

Vegan Fries

Served with housemade ketchup, chimichuri.

Vegan Tots

Served with housemade ketchup, chimichuri.

Vegan House Salad

Mixed greens, heart of palm, white balsamic dressing, nutritional yeast.
Vegan Wing (6) photo

Vegan Wing (6)

BBQ, Medium, Hot, or X-tra Hot.

Vegan Euro Trash Donuts

Vegan Deep Fried Oreos

BYO Pizza

BYO Pizza

Small 12" | Medium 14" | Large 16"

Toppings

Vegan Pepperoni, Banana Pepper, Spinach, Jalapeno, Black Olive, Onion, Cremini Mushroom, Pineapple, Green Pepper, Garlic, Kalamata Olive, Corn, Black Garlic, Arugula, Heart of Palm, Artichoke, Pinto Bean | Small | Medium | Large

Drizzles

Calabrian Chili Oil, Citrus, Balsamic Reduction, General Tso's Sauce, Black Truffle Oil, Sriracha | Small | Medium | Large

Vegan Pizza

Gluten Free Pizza Crust (10" only) available | Toppings: see regular pizza toppings, but only look at the ones that are vegan. You can look at the pepperoni too, though... because we have vegan pepperoni.

Vegan Pizza Masala

Vegan cheese, tikka masala sauce, chik'n, garlic, cilantro • 12" | 14" | 16"

Vegan General Tso

Vegan cheese, chik'n, broccoli, pineapple, garlic, general Tso's sauce • 12" | 14" | 16"

Vegan Truffle Shuffle

Black truffle oil, EVOO, vegan cheese, nutritional yeast, criminis, red onions, garlic • 12" | 14" | 16"

Vegan Margarita

Vegan cheese, EVOO, nutritional yeast, tomato, garlic • 12" | 14" | 16"

Don't Worry, Be Vegan

Onion, mushroom, vegan cheese, EVOO, garlic, arugula, balsamic reduction • 12" | 14" | 16"

Special Pairings

Dom N' Vegan Dogs

Vegan corn dogs (4) and a bottle of Dom Perignon
  • Order
  • Parties